Personalize IMDb Home IMDb Home
Top
Movies
| Photo
Galleries
| IMDb
Recommends
| Browse
IMDb
| Independent
Film
 

Search IMDb.com

 

Overview
( ) main details
( ) combined details
( ) full cast and crew
( ) company credits
Awards & Reviews
(o) user comments
( ) external reviews
(X) newsgroup reviews
( ) awards & nominations
( ) user ratings
( ) recommendations
Plot & Quotes
( ) plot summary
( ) plot keywords
( ) Maltin summary
( ) memorable quotes
Fun Stuff
( ) trivia
( ) goofs
( ) soundtrack listing
(X) crazy credits
( ) alternate versions
( ) movie connections
Other Info
( ) merchandising links
( ) box office & business
( ) release dates
(X) filming locations
( ) technical specs
( ) laserdisc details
( ) DVD details
( ) literature listings
(X) news articles
Promotional
( ) taglines
( ) trailers
( ) posters
(X) photo gallery
External Links
(X) on tv, schedule links
( ) showtimes
(X) official site
( ) miscellaneous
(X) photographs
(X) sound clip(s)
( ) video clip(s)
 
Advert


Actors Who Direct
You know them as popular actors, but they have also directed films of their own. Click on the face below for a sample of the actor's directorial work.
Edward NortonPenny MarshallSean Penn
Sally FieldForest WhitakerDiane Keaton
Kevin CostnerJodie FosterEd Burns




IMDb user comments for
Pink Floyd The Wall (1982)

PageFlicker
IMDb home PreviousMain DetailsNext Help
Page 5 of 31


 PINK FLOYD THE...
 Amazon.com 
Amazon USA
 VHS  Available on VHS (NTSC)
 DVD  Available on Region 1 DVD
 CD  no CD

Also available:
   Auctions
   Memorabilia
   Books
   All Products

Amazon.com

Comments index for Pink Floyd The Wall (1982)

wwe3

Date: 27 February 2001
Summary: Pink Floyd's music lends itself to the art of film perfectly.

Pink Floyd's music lends itself to the art of film perfectly. Visually stunning, this film captures you from the moment it starts and keeps you drawn in. "The Wall" can be enjoyed on many levels. For those who haven't seen it, you will be impressed by how well the film was made.

All who had a hand in this production did a great job. Director Alan Parker is a director who has ahead of his time. "The Wall" rivals many films today that try to blend animation and live action, this film flows in and out of animation gracefully. One of the best things about this film is it's design; designer Gerald Scarfe really puts you into the music. The sets, props, and scenes are well crafted. Every scene has an artistic feel. The story comes from Roger Water, he took his idea and made it an album, a film, and one of the best traveling arena/theater shows, enough said.

This film is best viewed in a theater and not that hard to find (usually a midnight showing, or at an on-campus theater). If you are renting/buying do yourself a favor and see it in letterbox. The film is too claustrophobic in pan and scan; and you miss the presentation. Plus Gerald Scarfe's brilliant designs, were meant to be seen as a whole.

If you like Pink Floyd, or just enjoyed the film. Try these other films that Pink Floyd did the soundtrack:

"More", "The Final Cut", "Zabriskie Point", and "Tonight Let's All Make Love In London".


wwe3

Date: 27 February 2001
Summary: Pink Floyd's music lends itself to the art of film perfectly.

Pink Floyd's music lends itself to the art of film perfectly. Visually stunning, this film captures you from the moment it starts and keeps you drawn in. "The Wall" can be enjoyed on many levels. For those who haven't seen it, you will be impressed by how well the film was made.

All who had a hand in this production did a great job. Director Alan Parker is a director who has ahead of his time. "The Wall" rivals many films today that try to blend animation and live action, this film flows in and out of animation gracefully. One of the best things about this film is it's design; designer Gerald Scarfe really puts you into the music. The sets, props, and scenes are well crafted. Every scene has an artistic feel. The story comes from Roger Water, he took his idea and made it an album, a film, and one of the best traveling arena/theater shows, enough said.

This film is best viewed in a theater and not that hard to find (usually a midnight showing, or at an on-campus theater). If you are renting/buying do yourself a favor and see it in letterbox. The film is too claustrophobic in pan and scan; and you miss the presentation. Plus Gerald Scarfe's brilliant designs, were meant to be seen as a whole.

If you like Pink Floyd, or just enjoyed the film. Try these other films that Pink Floyd did the soundtrack:

"More", "The Final Cut", "Zabriskie Point", and "Tonight Let's All Make Love In London".


Scott
Adelaide, Australia

Date: 12 February 2001
Summary: A Timeless rock Classic

Pink Floyd a group that knows no boundries when it comes to international issues in their music. Obviously influenced by some twisted minds the music and video come together remarkably well and have you thinking about what the music means rather than just hearing the movie. I'm 25 years old and love Pink Floyds music for what it is History in Rhyme.


(apkacdh@aol.com)
North Carolina

Date: 19 January 2001
Summary: Have you ever felt it?

Has this ever happened to you? Complete and utter alienation from everyone so much that you wind up shutting everyone out (and yourself in, in the process)? A complete state of misanthropy (hatred, contempt and/or distrust of humankind, for those of you who don't have a dictionary)? The kind of alienation from anyone, regardless of age, race, sex, or anything because they truly are the same (F***ing human beings!)? Where even the ones up high (the so-called "civilized") who've had everything handed to them on a silver platter (both metaphorically and literally) are such utter scum that you can't tell the difference between them and the so-called lowest, who have to dig in the dumpster for the day's food and scrounge your hard-earned money so they can drink or take drugs to numb the indignity of their situation?

Have you ever been lied to for practically your entire life by almost everyone around you? Not only by the bullies in your school/s, but even by your teachers, by the "Highly educated and therefore qualified" doctors who analyzed you, and even by the relatives you thought you could depend on who treated you like you were some kind of incompetent or invalid? And then you found out you were actually the exact opposite (not just above the "average" but even PAST that), and therefore you have trouble trusting the opinions or anything those around you may say or suggest?

Have you ever made the mistake of listening to people's views on anything whatsoever and then found out that their actions were totally contradictory to what they said they believed in?

And, if you're a performer of any kind whatsoever (let alone a famous one, be you a musician, comedian, actor, etc.), have you ever felt that kind of alienation from those who dig your stuff? When most people take your material totally differently from what it's supposed to mean? Like, when you're being serious, they're taking it as the latest trend or maybe you're satirizing what you're really feeling? Or, on the other hand, you can't stand your audiences anymore because you've gotten to that point when they're so drone-like to you that it seems like they'd jump off a high building if you said for them to do so?

Have you ever felt that kind of alienation where you can't trust anyone, not doctors, not religion, not your family, not even the hobbies you'd taken up since childhood, and even the drugs or alcohol (perscription or otherwise) you took to cloud the pain while dealing with all this doesn't work anymore?

You can't feel anything anymore, not for anything or anyone in the world, except maybe contempt, to say the least. And so you shut everyone out. EVERYONE AND EVERYTHING!!! (Goodbye Cruel World)

But, in the process, you're so shut in that you can't talk to anyone and no one can talk to you because THE WALL you've built is too thick for anyone to get through and too thick for you to break through as well. And, even worse, when you're tired of the alienation and you want to come back, even for a visit, you feel like you can't; not only because THE WALL is too thick to break through, but also because you don't feel anyone will understand what had happened to you. (Is There Anybody ... Out There?)

Well, if you've never felt these things, I'm not sure if you can really understand this movie on a personal level. But, at least the main character finally breaks through, so there's a happy note. Another happy note is that the makers of this film are concrete evidence that you're not the only one feeling that way.

That's how I take this film and the album anyway. Excellent!!!

P.S. Read also "The Bell Jar" by Sylvia Plath. Same basic concept, different metaphor (even though it came out way before "The Wall").


sasoldier

Date: 3 December 2000
Summary: greatest music video!

The Wall is to me my most worshiped film/musical of all time,and forever will be. Gerald Scarfs animated hammers and characters are fantastic. There should be more albums like The Wall as now everything is to similar now.Originality is fading!

stephen welch. 03/12/00.


jeek
houston/austin tx

Date: 18 November 2000
Summary: they don't make films like this anymore

i can't think of any other american film in history that can compare to this. "pink floyd the wall" is an all out assault on the human senses.

i don't care if you like the music of pink floyd or not, underneath the hallucination cinematography and animation lies a sad yet powerful story of childhood pain and adult emptiness.

if your a film student, this movie should be on your list if you haven't seen it.


Gene Davison
Scotia, NY, USA

Date: 10 November 2000
Summary: A powerful cinematic milestone.

First off, let me say this is not a movie for the clinically depressed. This movie is brutally harsh and makes virtually no attempt to tell the watchers things don't always go this bad in life. In fact, it seems to go out of it's way to drill into your head just how horrible life is.

That said, onto the review. The movie depicts the descent into madness of a fictional rock star named Pink Floyd. The events that lead up to this mental breakdown are depicted through confused, random, and fairly hallucinogenic memories of the aforementioned rock star. There is very little actual dialogue in the film but the story instead is unfolded through the songs of the Pink Floyd CD The Wall. The movie requires the introspection of the viewer to truly understand the symbolism and messages being sent throughout the film.

There are very few actors in the movie that are not cameo roles as well, the only truly constant actors are Pink, the schoolmaster, Pink's wife, Pink's mother, and young Pink. While the movie cannot be called taxing to a person's acting talent (pretty much they either stood their, smashed something, or walked from point A to point B) they were enjoyable to watch and you developed a feeling for them. What the feeling was definitely varies from person to person (was Pink a victim of his upbringing or was the building of the "wall" solely his own fault?).

The movie utilizes several key symbols throughout the film. The main symbol was the wall- the mental wall we build in our mind to keep out the hurt of the outside world. Another is the rag doll- used to express facelessness and defenselessness. There is a third even more important symbol in the film too- the marching hammers but that symbol is something so integral to the very thread of the movie that until you watch the film it is pointless to explain it.


iscream22
USA

Date: 14 October 2000
Summary: good film

If you like art, music, movies, then you will probably like this. This movie is somewhat depressing too. It's about a rockstar named pink, who goes crazy, and has to search through all of his odd and crazy memories to get back to the real world. It has both real people and animation, the ending is very memorable.


M. A. Rogers (docrog@sprynet.com)
New York City

Date: 25 September 2000
Summary: What's the term for "Better than a Masterpiece?"

Pink Floyd The Wall (1982)

Rating: 10.5 out of 10; What the rating means in my system: "Superb in every way. Everyone should be forced to watch it repeatedly."

The Wall is an example of genius in every respect, even if those responsible for the film don't seem to think it's flawless. It contains Incredible music, amazing cinematography, a gorgeously bleak story and visual elements, beautiful editing, etc. Every scene, every frame, is exquisite.

It began as a hint of an idea that occurred to Pink Floyd mastermind and bassist Roger Waters while the group was in the United States on tour in 1977 to support their album, Animals. They played mostly large arenas and stadiums. As Waters recounts on the excellent DVD version of The Wall, he realized that a majority of the audience could barely see or hear them. He felt increasingly alienated from the audience, who nevertheless seemed to blindly follow the band and accept this and who would entertain themselves in the nether portions of the venues by doing things like starting fires or fights. The alienation reached a peak when Waters spat on a fan trying to get close to the stage.

That spark, combined with a largely autobiographical account of Waters' youth (which was dominated by his existential angst at the premature loss of his father due to World War II, plus an understandably overprotective and overbearing mother and alienation with his schooling) begat The Wall--the album--Pink Floyd's programmatic, poignant, sprawling "rock opera." Upon creation, Waters already had the idea to do a film and an unusual, live, concept show, more akin to performance art than a typical rock concert and obviously Gerald Scarfe had already been contacted and developed the visual style that was to be used in the film's animation, since The Wall is adorned with the basic characters of the "Trial of Pink" sequence.

After the album was completed, work shortly began on the film. That's backwards to how most films are done--even musicals--and you might guess that it would create difficulties. Fortunately, other than Waters, who wrote the basic script, two other brilliant minds were involved--director Alan Parker (Midnight Express, Angel Heart, Angela's Ashes) and artist/animator Scarfe, who has a unique, surrealistic, disturbing style that was a perfect match with Waters' artistic vision.

Parker's first admirable decision, in parting from the original script, was that The Wall should have no Pink Floyd concert footage. Waters originally was going to have such scenes as audience members being bombed and applauding. As entertaining as that may have been, The Wall is better as a "normal" film; expository and cinematic. As good as Floyd's Live at Pompei is--and it is one of the best "concert" films, in my opinion--Parker's decision helped elevate The Wall to a rare 10.5. Apparently there was much in-fighting among the three men during the creative process, but artistic disagreements often seem to produce some of the best works--it means that those involved are passionate about their approach, and it means there will be an unusual mixture of styles. Besides, who doesn't fight with Waters?

The Wall tells us the story of a fictional character named Pink Floyd (Bob Geldof, who is amazing in the role). We begin in the present, with Pink sitting in a half-catatonic state in a hotel room. The camera pans down his arm and up to his face, where we enter Pink's mind and discover the source of his many neuroses. This brilliant idea allows Parker and Waters to present The Wall non-sequentially--a potentially confusing narrative idea that is pulled off without flaw here and adds much to the film's distinctive flavor.

The non-sequentiality also lends itself to presenting The Wall as a poetic pastiche of images, a technique that doesn't usually work for me--say, in something like The Thin Red Line or parts of The Exorcist--but which works perfectly here. The Wall is obviously a trip through the mind of Pink, and minds are things that jump around a lot. Neurotic minds are things that tend to obsess on certain events, and to portray that in film requires the technique that The Wall employs. That also helps explain the vacillation between live action shots and the more surreal animation. The animation is a realization of a subjective view of the events of Pink's life, and at times, such as the trial, represents a more hallucinatory psychotic break.

One common complaint about The Wall is that it is depressing. It certainly isn't a barrel of laughs--Waters even offers a criticism that The Wall is flawed for offering no laughs. I don't think that is a flaw, though. Conceivably, The Wall could have worked with some humor inserted, and there's a possibility it could still be a 10.5, but I think it needs to have an absence of laughter. Pink's life didn't have much humor in it. Waters objection is based on the fact that he has a sense of humor and humor is important to him. Pink isn't literally Waters though, as Waters also points out. I think that lightening the mood here and there would lessen the intense, consistent, ever-building mood that is The Wall's triumph.

With that in mind, The Wall isn't perhaps the best film if you need light entertainment. But If you want to see a heavy, dark masterpiece in every respect, you can't go wrong with it.


averroes-2
Chicago, IL

Date: 13 September 2000
Summary: A startling, twisted, difficult work of art; but eminently understandable in the end

The Wall is essentially about this absurd, twisted world as processed in the twisted mind of the protagonist. But the film is constructed in such a way as to pretty much allow you to grasp the trail to madness if you pay attention. Be warned. I'd bet that if you are not prepared to watch this film, it may drive you a bit mad yourself.

It has much to say about the world (war, politics, domination/submission, indoctrination, collectivist sentiment, human frailty/weakness/waste, the meaningless universe -- you name it.) I even read somewhere that the film turns a critical eye toward Pink Floyd's own potentially crazed fans; and I believe it. But it is bound together by the very personal and human, albeit tragic, journey of the main character. After seeing this film a few times, it has all become quite clear to me what sets him off, and generally why. In the end, it doesn't excuse any of the horrors, disappointments or hang-ups of life, nor does it excuse his main reaction to them (building the mental wall to protect himself/eliminate the source of pain.) It does grasp a bit at a bitter-sweet hope at the end in a way I only wish the tormented masses of the world could.

All in all a harrowing, but satisfying journey through a part of the psychological landscape we often would rather not see, but must face at one time or another.

Pretty amazing for a rock opera, I think.


jeeves96

Date: 13 September 2000
Summary: A national anthem of life itself

This movie tells about the life of a rock star who has isolated himself in a hotel room. Exploring the mind of Pink means learning of his past. From his father's death to his wife cheating on him, Pink Floyd has taken all of his fears(bricks) and built a wall with them. The wall is his isolation from the audience and the people. This movie has actually helped me to take out some of the bricks in MY life. Everytime I watch this movie I find something signifigant to my life and I'm sure all of yours. I owe it all to one man. Roger Waters, you have changed my life. Thanks for everything and thanks for helping me understand the true necessity in life.."TEAR DOWN THE WALL!!"


Francisco Huerta (fjhuerta@hotmail.com)
Mexico City

Date: 2 August 2000
Summary: A mad descent into an alienated mind

Pink Floyd's "The Wall" is a movie I heard so much about before finally watching it. Reason being, I never liked Floyd's music in the first place. Something about devil worship that someone at school told me.

As time passed, I discovered "Dark Side of the Moon", thanks in part to the engineering credits (I love everything Alan Parsons has done). The incredible workmanship of the album drew me closer to the group. And even then, "The Wall" was the last album I bought. Then, when the deluxe DVD edition came out, I jumped at it.

What can I say? I watched the movie 3 times, and I couldn't still fully understand it. I loved the animations and became intrigued by the inner motivations of the main character, although there were some parts of the movie I just couldn't make anything of it. Then I decided to watch the extra materials that came with the DVD, including the running commentary by Roger Waters. And it all made sense. This is one powerful movie, an interesting rebellion against rock stardom and its perks. It's completely unexpected, since we are listening to all of this from a rock star himself, which makes it all too real. The groupies, the drugs, the alienation, the feeling of being sick and fed up with it all.

This is not an uplifting movie by any means. In fact, Roger Waters summed it up pretty well describing it as "a sour 2 hours". And the fact that Mr. Waters has never been able to fully recover from the loss of his father makes it even worse (almost every Pink Floyd album - and a complete album, The Final Cut - has a song about his death in WWII). Even with this cons, the film is a must see for the animation sequences. And Bob Geldof proves he can act.


spazti
Berkeley, CA

Date: 19 July 2000
Summary: very good banal movie

This movie is strangely moving. However, there is little depth to it: We are all alienated by the mean people (teachers, parents, blah, blah..) All the images are cliches which makes it not so disturbing (which is Roger Water's intention). It's hard to be frightened by teeny-boppers shouting "heil pink"

At the same time, I loved it. I don't know if it is 'cause I'm a Pink Floyd fan but I couldn't get enough of it. This is best music/album film ever because it has no concert footage (which is not much considering "Stop Making Sense" is the second best) Perhaps the conversion of an album to a film is just too limiting. Hopefully somebody will eventually prove me wrong.


batt138
indiana

Date: 29 June 2000
Summary: unforgettable

one of the most powerful, moving, and creative pieces of cinema. This movie is for everybody...it relates to everybody in some sort of way and has a very powerful message at the end. It is the story of a man's breakdown due to his own personal problems and what he has to do in the end to get through it. Though depressing at times, do sit through the whole thing. This film is a wonderful piece of art in which much can be learned. One thing i would suggest is to get it one DVD and watch it with the subtitles since it will give those who are not familiar with the album a better understanding of the images and messages that are being conveyed.


Gazzer-2
USA

Date: 22 June 2000
Summary: A Powerful Rock Film....IF You Can Handle It

I'm always thrilled when some of my favorite conceptual rock albums in my music collection are turned into movies. Nobody's made a film version yet of "The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway" by Genesis (too strange, perhaps?), but there are, indeed, movie adaptations of "Tommy" & "Quadrophenia" by The Who, "Jesus Christ Superstar," and, of course, THIS film, Alan Parker's 1982 film adaptation of the classic rock opera, "The Wall," by the British group Pink Floyd. So successful was the "Wall" album (which continues to sell briskly to this day), that a film version was inevitable, and, for the most part, the film version does the album justice.

A famous rock star named Pink (Bob Geldof), having played too many shows, consumed too many drugs, is estranged from his cheating wife & has painful memories of his father being killed in the war, slowly starts to go mad, and builds a mental "wall" around himself, piece by piece, brick by brick....Like the original Floyd album, the movie version of "The Wall" is no less depressing OR powerful. Obviously, there's no faulting Pink Floyd's music here, which is taken directly from the original "Wall" album (rather than re-recorded from scratch like in the film of the Who's "Tommy"), and of course, the music is pure classic Floyd. Bob Geldof is powerful as the tortured Pink, Alan Parker's direction is impressive, Gerald Scarfe's animations are appropriately creepy, and the film's stereophonic sound is guaranteed to floor you.

However, considering the thoroughly heavy subject matter, and the film's relentless sensory attack on the audience, some have found the film to be too much of an overwhelming downer, and quite honestly, I can't argue with them. Even former Pink Floyd frontman Roger Waters, the main creator of "The Wall," finally confessed in 1987 that when HE saw "The Wall" movie for the very first time, his observation of the film was that "it seemed to start bashing you over the head in the first ten minutes, and it didn't stop until it was over; there was no quiet time." No disagreements here.

Nonetheless, if you're strong enough to brave this film---and if you're a Pink Floyd fan who's familiar with this classic album, besides---then turn down the lights, crank up the volume on your TV set, and get ready for 100 minutes of music video assault that will rock you AND shake you, as you're taken along with Pink on a journey through the madness of a burnt-out rock star. For better or worse, "Pink Floyd: The Wall" is a rock movie journey you're not likely to forget.


Jeff (spoonjef@aol.com)
L.A. CA

Date: 21 May 2000
Summary: A mad merging of live action, animation, and music.

You don't watch The Wall, you're absorbed into it. The music of Pink Floyd is fused together with Alan Parker's striking images and Gerald Scarfe's brilliant animation. As Pink slowly descends into madness, we are given a first hand look at what has brought him to this point. The loss of his father, his relationship with his mother and wife, the teachers at the public school he attended and the burdens of rock stardom, all fit together to form his wall, that will eventually isolate him from society. Once inside his wall, Pink goes through some changes and eventually puts himself on trial. Scarfe's hallucinatory animation brings to life many songs from the album and gives the film a feel unlike any other. Parker directs the live action with fire. One of the best sequences in the film is in the beginning. As the housekeeper fiddles with Pink's door, we see in his mind a door locked with a chain move slightly. Then, when the door opens and is stopped by the chain, the doors in Pink's mind fly open and thousands of fans rush in. Then, Parker cuts to soldiers charging over beachheads as explosions scorch the land. All of this is set to In The Flesh, the first track off of the album. It's hard to talk about The Wall, in this forum. The Wall is a film that needs to be seen, heard and absorbed in order to understand it.


robert frangie frangie (robertfrangie@hotmail.com)
Leon, Gto. Mexico

Date: 20 May 2000
Summary: A Mad Piece of Cinema!

Alan Parker has always had a gift for the integration of music and film, and his efforts over the years have reflected that. Movies like "Fame" (1980) & "The Commitments" (1991) have made him a director more remembered for his music video skills than his storytelling, even though he directed gripping controversial more seriously films, like "Midnight Express" (1978) & "Mississippi Burning" (1988).

"The Wall" tells the account of a rock star's breakdown, Pink Floyd slowing down into madness..Pink's madness is illustrated with living flashbacks of his life..He has visions of his childhood from a baby hold in the cradle to his present moment. We have little Pink suffering from alienation for the death of his father in the war..& taken under the care of his mother..We have also rock & roll star Pink, who is destroyed by his evident insanity and is driven over the edge by his wife's infidelity and we have a blown insane Pink (going so foolish as to shave his own eyebrows) a Nazi dictator under the Hammer Regime leading a series of occurrences like raping, breaking & pillaging..

Alan Parker translates the music into memorable images that are insensible to love or pity..All of Pink's life is projected on the screen. We see & hear songs like "Another Brick In the Wall, Part II" altered from an abstract concept into a disgusting vision of students being thrown into a meat grinder..

Pink constructs the wall by building up tension (the night he came along to the hotel with a frenzy young group and reveals all his hidden emotions in a violent disturbing climax). Mixing up sexuality and violence was creating a new window into Pink's character..The animated sequences that reflected Pink's foolishness were important and influential.

Alan Parker's direction moves the story cleverly from the present into the past and into a possible future, drawing a warning : 'War is disagreeable..War is unwelcome'..but still contemplating traumas of a child with hurtful effects on the fully grown man..The result is 'a mad piece of cinema'..a kind of a bad dream becoming even worse than usual.

The film exploit great special effects (some frightful and impossible to understand). The music praises the film so well from declaring noisy rock & roll music to quiet ballads of insanity (a fine sound track & an over-extended best- selling rock album)

Bob Geldof was amazing as Pink, the British rock star broken in pieces under the psychological pressure of an American Tour.

Pink Floyd-The Wall - a bizarre animation reinforcing its vision of an insane,inhumane, unjust & cruel world.. not easy to follow - stands out as one of the classic in the teenage scene, specially teenagers who take or receive narcotic and due to its psychedelic nature - induced both by the music & the photography - leaves you greatly depressed.


(anon1mat0@yahoo.com)
Hallandale, FL

Date: 19 May 2000
Summary: Not Only for rock fans

One of the things that had amazed me reading the comments on this movie is that almost everybody who comment on it is a Pink Floyd fan or related. Perhaps it shouldn't come as a surprise but the issue here is that the movie has to be valued as a movie and not as a 90 minutes MTV clip. Almost all of what is said in this movie can be applied to not only the british but to the western society as well. The fans (and I have to admit that I also love the music) put to much attention to the personal facts of Roger Waters and forget that this is not a simple personal case of madness but the simptoms of a sick society which still carries the burden of the war, racism, and the overwhelming cult to its "successful" individuals. This movie is a piece of art, perhaps one of Alan Parker's best.


Harry Perales (jedi_harry84@hotmail.com)
Spring,TX

Date: 28 April 2000
Summary: I haven't said it all yet!

I am sure I have already commented on this particular film, but on further inspection I have a lot more to say.

Many people watch "The Wall" without knowing anything of the album or even Pink Floyd! If you are not perceptive and ponder deeply when you watch a film, then so God help me, listen to the album first!

Luckily, I had barely heard anything by Pink Floyd and yet still understood it pretty much fully, except for somethings I undertstand now. But then again, I can find a biblical or other kind of reference to anything.

There are many things written in the lyrics that are not in the actual songs. For example: "The Trial"-The only thing I couldn't understand in the whole film was who the hell the red headed monster in the trial scene was. But on more viewings I realize that it was in more scenes. But when I read the Lyrics it said: "Call the wife", and even more odd, they included that in their live shows as well.

Another thing to know, if you don't own the album, get it! you WILL like it. And you shall understand the story alot better.

This film is a story about all of us. Roger Water's story of mental destruction and blocking yourself from the outside world, hence creating a WALL.

All of us have a "wall", but some haven't finished it yet. Don't finish it. And if you do, tear it down. That is the message in this film. No matter how bad life is, do not let those bad things get to you. No matter what.

All of us have a little Pink in us, but some just tend to not show it. Which is a bad thing, because you have already built a Wall blocking your real self. Don't be like Pink, just be your self!

Rating:A+


Filmjack3
Jersey

Date: 9 April 2000
Summary: Parker's Best

Pink Floyd's The Wall is a great piece of cinema. Not only because of Roger Waters, Gerald Scarfe and Alan Parker adding to the film, but because the Album is also one of the best ever. The songs added to this film make it one big music video (and a great one at that) with a cool if not confusing (not too confusing) story.

Comments index for Pink Floyd The Wall (1982)


See the next 20 comments, there are 70 in total.

Read customer reviews at Amazon.com.

Add another comment